Book review: Northern Lights by Philip Pullman (His Dark Materials #1)

Rating: ★★★★★

Northern Lights is the first book in the His Dark Materials fantasy trilogy by Philip Pullman. The first book is also known as The Golden Compass in the US, and it follows a young girl named Lyra and her animal daemon Pan, as they discover that a group of people are kidnapping children and taking them to the freezing north to conduct obscure experiments on them.


I wanna start off by saying that I adored this book. The setting is fantastic. I love stories that deal with northern exploration, so travelling through the snow and ice with these characters was wonderful for me. There’s lots of travelling involved in general, so we get to see cities, small towns, the ocean, and finally the bitter cold north.

For a fantasy novel, the setting is quite unusual. The universe is much like ours, just more magical – the book starts in England, at the University of Oxford, and later we even get to see London. The world is different in a lot of ways, but a big part of it is recognisable, which I found very interesting. The north reminds me of Siberia – a freezing region with lots of untouched land. The place where they conduct the strange experiments also makes me think of northern Russia because of all the stories there are about secret operations up there. It’s definitely a unique setting for a fantasy novel.

The experiments conducted on the children are terrifying and heartbreaking. Every time someone talked about them, Lyra would feel desperate and sick. In most books when the main character feels that way I can’t identify with those feelings, but in this story I almost felt worse than Lyra. Maybe it’s just me, but I was absolutely horrified.

The characters are fascinating and all very memorable. Lyra is a curious child who doesn’t take shit from anyone, and while some people find her annoying, I really enjoyed reading about her. She’s pretty bad-ass for such a young girl and I loved how she got herself out of a lot of complicated situations instead of waiting to be saved by someone else. She’s quite bossy and likes to have control over everything, which I also thought was pretty awesome. Her friends are mostly street-kids or servants at the university, and they’re all boys, so she grew up playing outside, fighting with the other kids and exploring the city – as a result she’s not scared of the world and grew up to be kind of a rebel. We also get to meet Mrs. Coulter, who is the most unlikable character I’ve ever had to read about. She’s the kind of fancy lady who acts all kind and gentle but is secretly just a cold-blooded killer. Every time she showed up somewhere I wanted the ceiling to fall down and kill her. Ugh, I hate that woman.

Apart from the main characters, we also get to meet some very unusual people. There are the armoured bears for example – they are beautiful, white bears who live in the north and wear armour, and they talk and think like humans. Animals are very interesting in this trilogy in general – the whole daemon concept is very unique and wonderful, for example. Basically, every human being has a daemon, which is an animal who represents their soul. Humans are born with their daemons, they’re a part of them, and it’s impossible to live without them. As a big animal-lover, I found the idea quite lovely.

The most interesting aspect of the series, however, is the imagery. My favourite Booktuber, Jen Campbell, made a series of videos (this onethis one, this one and this one) with her friend Holly talking about all the imagery in the books, and I watched those videos before reading the first book, so it was quite easy for me to spot all the metaphors and the hidden meanings. The books talk more or less subtly about sexuality, growing up and the whole idea of sin, which was really fascinating. I especially love how Lyra, at the end of the first book, comes to the conclusion that sin is actually not a bad thing, that it’s good and should be embraced. I can’t even imagine how controversial that must have been when the book was released. Pullman also dismisses the idea that growing up is bad and that the ultimate goal is to stay a child; Jen and Holly discussed in their videos how His Dark Materials is sort of a response to the idea of growing up in The Chronicles of Narnia and Peter Pan – in those two works, growing up is seen as a bad thing, and Philip Pullman wanted to write a children’s story where it’s clear that there is nothing wrong with growing up and “losing your innocence”.

There are a few things I didn’t like about this book. The first one is Lyra’s way of talking. Most of the time she talks like an uneducated child, with bad grammar and specific expressions, which I think is due to the fact that all her friends talk like that, so she adapts. However, every once in a while she suddenly starts talking like some kind of desperate Disney princess, saying things like “oh, I hope you’re not hurt, my dear!”. That just seemed completely out of place – she’s a rebel, a wild girl who fights and doesn’t like to be pretty. So why in the world would she talk like that? Then the pacing was a bit strange at times. It would go from fast-paced, on-the-edge-of-your-seat kind of moments to slow scenes with lots of talking, and I found that this kind of took me out of the story. I also have to say that I really didn’t like the ending, but I’m not gonna go into any details because I don’t wanna spoil it for you.

I’m definitely excited to get my hands on the second book in the series. I watched the (terrible) movie of the first one a few years ago, so I knew the plot more or less, but I have no idea what the other two books are about.


If you guys have read this series, I would love to talk about it in the comments below (keep in mind I’ve only read the first book so far). And if you haven’t, I hope I could interest you in picking it up.

‘Till next time and happy reading!



19 thoughts on “Book review: Northern Lights by Philip Pullman (His Dark Materials #1)

  1. I read the first two books in this series when I was a kid, but I remember absolutely nothing about them! I think I was probably too young to appreciate them. I definitely need to dig out my copies and read them again, they sound fantastic 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s been ages since I read the series, so I don’t remember the details–but this review is perfect (both your praise and your criticism), and you’ve made me want to reread the books asap. Can’t wait to see what you have to say about the other books!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I love this book! Like Liam though, I don’t remember the details at all. I don’t remember liking the movies so much. I remember meeting Phillip Pullman a few years ago though, and he pretty much said what you have summarised with this review: that growing up and losing your innocence isn’t bad at all. Really great review! This was one of the books I read as a teen that just resonated with me a lot.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I was literally just thinking earlier yesterday/today that I need to re-read this series, and your review has made me want to pick it up even more!
    I agree with you the movie was terrible, but oh the second and third books are so so brilliant so if you liked this one then I reckon you LOVE The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass. When are you planning to start the second one?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh dear, first I need to get through my TBR, which is 14 books right now. Then I’ll order some new ones and I’m not sure if the second book will be one of them, because I just have so many books I wanna read! I definitely wanna finish the trilogy this year tho haha.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I do admire the fact that you work through your TBR list before buying new books, if I did that I wouldn’t spend so much each month 😀
        Well hopefully you do get to the second and third book before the year is over then, at least the whole trilogy has been released so you won’t have to wait for any of the books!

        Liked by 1 person

    1. What, really? Why didn’t you like it? I’ve seen a few people giving it low ratings and I have no idea why haha. Unless your reason is spoilery for the other two books, then I don’t wanna know. 😀


      1. The books just felt lifeless to me. I guess an underlying philosophy of “we’re all going to die and turn to nothing and nothing really matters” isn’t appealing to me.

        I also found the jabs at the Catholic Church off-putting. Sure, you can criticize organized religion, but it seems a bit low to paint the Church as experimenting on children and doing things like giving absolution before a sin (I think that may have happened in the Middle Ages, but it’s definitely not a thing today and I think even people in the Middle Ages would have recognize that as illogical and an abuse of power.) I guess I want my critiques of religion to be more logical, as well, and to address present problems rather than making up evil deeds to create an emotional appeal against the Church? Like Dante was pretty critical of the papacy but everything he said was happening was actually happening.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s